Teaching
Experiences in Shanghai, China
see also.. Teaching
English in China
An
increasing number
of people are becoming attracted to opportunities to teach English
in China. Most of
those who do so have
an extremely positive and enjoyable experience.
However, some have experienced difficulties.
The
most common problems encountered arise
from being faced with living or working conditions that do not meet
expectations
and complications over obtaining the correct visas and residence
permits. There have
also been complaints of breach of
contract, confiscation of passports and of payment being withheld.
To
give you an insight into teaching in Shanghai (China) we have published
advice
found on blogs relating to the subject. It must be remembered
that we cannot verify these accounts so take them 'as' is.
If
you wish to take
up teaching appointments in China it is illegal to work on a tourist or
business visa, and we advise you to contact the nearest Chinese
Diplomatic
Mission for information on obtaining the appropriate
documentation. In addition, you should
research the
educational establishment and the area in which you intend to work as
thoroughly as possible. Further
information can be found in the consular area of the web-site of the
British
Embassy Beijing at website:
http://www.uk.cn.
Experiences
Learning
Education Center,
Shanghai.
Shanghai is a wonderful city with
many good schools. However some are just too dishonest for words and
should be
avoided.
I am a university professor and
only
teach English in my holidays. I have made it a policy to avoid small
private
schools, who may get into financial difficulties, and then not pay you,
but last
summer I was caught out by a big school in Shanghai.
Post-SARS, there were few native
English teachers available in Shanghai and I worked extended hours for
Learning
Education center, (L-E-C), which was desperately short of teachers.
They made a
mistake with my salary the first month, which they promised to fix the
next
month. They had paid me at a rate of 150 RMB per hour, instead of the
agreed 220 RMB. The next
month produced no change
and I was underpaid again.
During
the final month they were to pay me a combination of back pay and the
total for
that month. NOTHING!!! They paid me nothing at all!
When I contacted the owner he
informed me that I would be physically beaten if I complained, to teach
me
respect for Chinese, and then he would have me deported. Almost a year
later I
am still out of pocket for more than 16,000 RMB.
What can I do? The Education Bureau
is in his pocket and the school is prepared to say anything to
discredit me.
Lawyer friends say there is little that can be done except warn others,
or take
a large group of men and beat offer them violence.
I have since discovered that many
other teachers have suffered delayed and incorrect payments. Even
Chinese
assistants complained to me they were not paid on time.
This is a re-repost of an item that
was originally found on “Nate’s Chinese School Review”. Courtesy of:
chinaschoolreview.net
Top
of page
Raffles
Lasalle Shanghai
Andy
says:
You will work long hours for little
personal reward or recognition. You MUST work a nine hour day. They
have a
questionable evaluation system and even more questionable curriculum.
The people in charge of you know nothing about ESL teaching and do not
really
care if students are learning or not as long as the wheels keep turning.
The rules and systems and policies, such as they are, will change on a
daily
basis. Your contract is worthless.If you are sick, you must teach the
classes
you missed upon your return.
Oh yeah, each class is four hours long. Look before you leap man or the
water
may just be too deep.
They pay on time. Every time. You
get a legal work visa and all other necessary paperwork. Your
colleagues are generally
wonderful.The students are sweet
(if somewhat unenthusiastic about English)
This is not an English school. They
use the HEADWAY text books. I will say no more.
The Singaporean entrepreneurs who pride themselves on running this
pseudo
educational institution care ONLY about money.
Shanghai
Normal University, English
First Shanghai (EF Shanghai) Shanghai
Native speaker 1
says:
Foreign teachers at Shanghai Normal
University–even relative old timers–were given only one-semester
contracts this
past September. The reason now seems to have emerged: the school on
Guilin Lu
in south Shanghai has contracted with corporate English First to run
its
one-year mandatory oral English course for third-year students. It
appears that
English First not only will supply the curriculum and supervision but
also will
have an HR function in determining what teachers will be rehired for
the spring
semester . . . And, of course, who won’t be rehired.
Top
of page
TEFL
Jobs Consulting Ltd Company
Dos
says:
I agree
with the post about TEFL CC.
We hired a teacher using them and an agent.
The school paid the agent
his fees
but the agent
then wouldn’t pay the
teacher his salary.
The school withheld further payment that was requested, as he had
failed to pay
the teacher. Don’t use!
Cheery
English
Richard
says:
The company likes to tell “white” lies and
will bend the contract
rules. They
also made me work extra hours, more than stated in my contract, and I
was NEVER
paid for these extra hours!
They are not legally licensed to hire foreigners, so instead of getting
us our
Z visas like they are supposed to, they instead make us pay extra money
for
other documents so they can just extend the visa. They won’t and they
can’t get
teachers a foreign expert certificate because they are not a legal
company.
Not worth the time, PLEASE, when working in China, make sure the
company or
school has a OVERSEAS EMPLOYMENT LICENSE.
Michaelangello
says:
This company is just a middleman.
They are not legally licensed to hire foreigners and they do not follow
contract. They will bend the rules and not pay you correctly. You will
not be
paid for overtime or for covering other teachers. If you are a
substitute
teacher, they will not pay you for it, rather they will tell you to
collect the
money from the other teacher you worked for!
The do not follow contract and will cheat you if they can. They go
through many
Chinese and Foreign teachers quickly because of their dishonest ways.
English First Shanghai (EF
Shanghai)
// Shanghai Shanghai
Anonymous
says:
I clear almost 9,000 rmb a month
and
my contract is 30 ach (40 mins each) any more has to be mutually agreed
and is paid overtime.
Half my flight money has been paid and the rest will be at the end of
my
contract.
Accommodation is satisfactory without being luxurious!
I average
about 27 ach a week and
dont have to come in when not working.
Top
of page
Enlighten / Enlightenment
Consultants // Shanghai Shanghai
Steve
says:
I have just received a phone call
from Enlighten / Enlightenment Consultants this afternoon (the company
that I
work for) saying that they are firing me and I have to leave my
accommodation by
tomorrow.
All through last term I was on time for every lesson and didn’t have 1
single
day sick leave.I also did o/t each week at Kindergarten’s to help them
out and
to boost my poor wages.
Gold
Apple Bilingual School // Shanghai Shanghai
Kris
says:
My experience at Shanghai Gold Apple
Bilingual School was good at times
and bad
at others. The pay was relatively low yet they always pay on time.
There was a
travel bonus which was nice and they paid for my round trip ticket from
the
U.S. They paid for travel visas and work visas. Accommodations and
meals
were
free. Accommodations were not fabulous in terms of a kitchen but we did
have
heat and AC. The children were good and other teachers were extremely
kind.
“The Chinese way” is something I never learned to deal with and
ultimately made
me decide to leave after one year. Promises by the school for Chinese
lessons
were not honored. I only had to teach 18 classes a week with most of
them 40
minutes and a few 30 minutes. Bring your own teaching materials!!!!!!
Kongjiang
High School // Shanghai
Daniel
says:
- Accommodation - Forget about an
apartment or anything like that, even
by SH
standards of apartment living.
- There is a telephone that will accept calls, but they have
steadfastly
ignored my requests for a line that calls outside the school to be
installed.
- What you agree
upon with
administration will probably be ignored.
Top
of page
Posted
in Teach ESL in Shanghai
|
Thinking about teaching English in
Shanghai? I’ve been doing it for a few months; here are some
observations. This is not meant to take the place of doing your own
research -– if you are serious about getting a teaching job here you
probably already know where to look -– and it won’t tell you what the
best schools are. Rather, I want to give a flavor of the sort of thing
you should expect and what you should be looking out for. I came here
completely fresh –- not only had I never been in China before, I had
never taught before either. I got my job, with one of the bigger
schools in Shanghai, pretty easily: I did a CELTA course, was
interviewed in my home country and then by phone from Shanghai, and got
on a plane. The whole process, from starting the course, took under
three months. Many people do it faster than that.
|
|
|
The opening weeks passed
pretty damn quickly. There was accommodation to find, forms to fill
out, maps to read. Classes to take over. Five days after getting off
the plane I was teaching a six-hour day. I had the requisite nightmare
kids class, which still remains by far the worst class I have taught.
By now I feel like I’ve been teaching for years.
My experience has been pretty good.
I love the job. I love, almost without exception, the students. I think
they consider me a decent teacher; I’m pretty sure that whether they do
or not they like me personally. (The job would be unbearable if it were
otherwise. I’d have quit by now rather than keep teaching people I
don’t like.) You’ll discover that it’s not that difficult to find work
as an English teacher here, no matter what your experience level.
|
|
For now, the market is booming.
There’s plenty of competition and schools are opening every day. Even
teachers who don’t have particularly glowing recommendations from
previous schools find work. Here are some things to keep an eye out for
when looking for a job:
- What do you know about the school?
If the only evidence you have that the school even exists is one
internet ad, be very wary.
- Always check TEFL websites --
Dave’s Internet Café and tefl.com are good
ones -- before committing to anything. If teachers have been badly
treated –- and stories in China abound, though less so in the big
cities –- they will let other people know. If nobody has heard of a
school, it may be small, or new, and may be perfectly alright. On the
other hand, it might be dodgy, and you don’t want to find that all the
promises made to you have evaporated by the time your feet touch
Chinese soil.
- With the more established big
companies such as English First or Wall Street, I can’t guarantee you a
pleasant experience, but you are not going to be financially cheated.
|
|
Top
of page
Try to find out if your boss –-
i.e. academic coordinator, director of studies, the job title varies –-
has been there long. Other teachers in the city tell me that having a
new person in charge of you every couple of months is stressful and can
lead to schedule chaos. Make sure the school pays for your return fare
here. Generally you will be asked to buy the ticket yourself in your
home country -– make sure they agree
in writing (i.e. email) that the price you quote them is alright.
Standard procedure is for the school to pay you half the cost in your
first pay cheque, and half when you complete your contract.
Also, make sure that if they don’t provide accommodation (they are less
likely to in Shanghai than in other parts of China,) they will put you
up for free for at least a fortnight when you arrive. Shanghai
landlords often ask for one or two months rent as deposit, plus up to
the first three months rent in advance, so you may have to find a fair
bit of cash at once.
It’s definitely worth checking if the
school will advance you some salary, interest-free, to help you out. It
was something I hadn’t considered and I would have been in trouble if
the school hadn’t been obliging about it.Make sure the school commits
to take care of, and pay for, all visas and legal documentation.
You may be asked to get a standard
tourist entry visa in your home country and then change it once you’re
here – this is fine and perfectly legal, though don’t mention that this
is what you’re doing when you’re filling out forms. Keep the receipt
and get that repaid in your first pay cheque. By the time I had visited
all the offices, filled out all the forms, done the medical and so on I
had made at least five separate journeys to various parts of the city.
Make sure in advance that the school will always send someone to
accompany you and tell you what to do -– and in practice fill out most
of the forms for you. You shouldn’t have to pay any money for any of
this.
Most contracts are for a year,
though shorter ones do exist. You’ll probably have a probation period
during which you can be let go pretty easily. You’ll also lose the
second half of your airfare (NOT the first half). Be aware of this and
have a fall back plan, even if the fallback plan consists only of the
phone numbers of other schools in Shanghai. Your working documents will
probably tie you to the school you first join, but if another employer
wants to hire you they should be able to change them without too many
headaches.
|
|
Again, there is nothing illegal
about this. Once you’re here, keep on top of the financial side. Make
sure you know what you’re supposed to get. Every teacher in every
school I know tells me the same thing, which is that you can’t expect
overtime to be automatically paid or pay slips to be correctly
calculated. Nobody I know feels there is any attempt to intentionally
cheat them, it’s simply a combination of incompetence and differing
work cultures. Be polite but firm.
Top
of page
|
|
|
This is not a good place to be
anxious about complaining. I haven’t had any big problems but other
people have.This may seem obvious, but think about why you’re going to
Shanghai. If, like me, you don’t intend to be a career teacher but are
using the job as a way to get out here pretty easily, then once you’ve
found your feet you should start looking into other options. This is
not to say you should break your contract –- I don’t intend to. But try
to put yourself in a position where you have options once a year’s up
and you want to move on. If you want to keep teaching, fine. You’ll
find that if you have a year’s experience and a good recommendation you
can get paid a bit more and pick and choose your jobs.
When
you’re trying to find your feet you’ll find that students will be
incredibly useful to you. If you get on well with them, they’ll be
incredibly solicitous and flatteringly interested in you. Use this. Let
them know if you intend to look for other work in the future in
Shanghai. Find out if they can help you. They’ll be happy to if they
can. I find the students -– and perhaps I am lucky in this, I can speak
only for myself –- are great. (The adults at least. Kids can be hard
work – often bright but spoiled and difficult.) They’re motivated,
smart and more open-minded than I’d expected.
|
|
I’m careful about certain
subjects, i.e. sex, politics (Taiwan, Tiananmen Square, Tibet), race,
but if they come up they come up and there’s no problem with it. I
certainly don’t pussyfoot around things and the students have no
problem stating their opinions or disagreeing
with each other. If we are discussing a controversial topic, I am very
clear about saying “Many people in the West think . . .” not “I think”
– after all, the idea is to have them practice their English, not
change their minds. And I wouldn’t presume to tell them what to think
anyway.
Then there’s the staff room. You’re
likely to have an interesting mix of ages
and backgrounds. There will be a fair number of people who don’t want
to be teachers for the rest of their life but want to do the job well
and professionally while they’re here. Generally teachers are very
professional – but everyone I know confirms that TEFL teaching also
attracts people who would have difficulty surviving in a normal job.
Some of them will be great fun because of this; some of them may be
insecure bores. You’ll hopefully make some close friends; you’ll
probably get on well with almost everybody.
The downside of
this job is that it only takes one misfit to bring the whole mood down
and a staff room is a tough place to be if there is bad feeling. A good
boss will be able to see this and move the person on.
There’ll be lots of turnover, which
has its pros and cons. You’ll say goodbye to friends; you’ll also be
well rid of people you don’t like.Get to know the local teachers, if
your school has them. Be nice to them. You’re going to need them.
They’ll help you with all the small stuff that is made difficult by the
language
barrier – calling the landlord, paying bills, explaining what the ayi
is trying to say to you. And they’re great for practicing your Chinese
on. You’ll already know that TEFL teachers don’t get paid a lot.
Obviously we’re a great deal better-off than millions of Shanghainese
who aren’t working in flashy big jobs.
However, plenty of
Chinese people will be making more money than you; and all the laowai
who have proper jobs will be able to buy and sell you. It’s pretty easy
to eat well and go about your daily life pretty cheaply, if you don’t
need a daily fix of Western food. But if you’re a drinker – and
teachers here do drink a lot – you’ll have to watch your money. Bars
here generally charge Western prices, which will make your salary
disappear pretty quickly if you go for a couple of drinks most nights.
A big night out can set me back for a couple of weeks.
There is hope though: every bar has
a happy hour, generally offering 2-for-1 type deals, and you’ll master
techniques for cheap drinking pretty quickly. There are also a few
cheaper bars – generally they’re not great, but they do the job if you
want to start there before going on to the nicer places. Teachers tend
to drink on Maoming Rd rather than the pricier Hengshan Rd or the
tackier Julu Rd -– but anywhere you go in town you’ll see them --
scruffy people who look like they need a good night’s sleep and are
probably talking too loudly.
As you can probably tell, I’m very
happy to be an English teacher in Shanghai. The good days outnumber the
bad ones. If you take the job, but not yourself, seriously you’ll fit
right in at any school. And if you’re good you can move up very
quickly. There are lots of teachers here, but the market’s far from
saturated. There are plenty of opportunities if you’re ambitious,
whether as a teacher or in a different field. If you know why you’re
here and you have some idea what you want, you’ll do fine.
|
Found
on expat website
Top
of page
|